Callouts & quotes from 572+ activist slides

"This begs three questions: 1) What is the value proposition of the Taexx system if homeowners don't even realize they have the system installed as a home buying benefit, 2) If conventional pest control sales were 90% of the business, and HomeTeam D2D marketers were successful, why does Rollins need Fox's marketers to push the use of Taexx, and 3) If HomeTeam's margins are well below corporate average, why is Rollins pushing investment in lower margin business?"

"Documents show Waterpik’s gross margins were 47.7% - 49.1% pre-acquisition, and the CFO said he expected 200 - 300bp gross margin expansion. Fast forward to early 2019, the CFO’s recent comment that gross margins are now “on par” with the company’s gross margin (pre-tariff), indicate that margins have contracted lower in this product line closer to 44% - and this even after price increases announced in Q3 2018!"

"As a producer of commodity products and ingredients, MGPI has to constantly innovate to maintain a competitive advantage against its larger peers that have substantially more resources and can easily out-spend it. MGPI holds very few patents, but as we highlighted earlier, its key patent rights to Fibersym® is set to expire in 2017 and could have a material adverse effect on margins."

"It appears that no matter the auditor in 2017 or 2022, there's a consistent warning that a critical audit matter relates to the carrying value of the assets. The current auditor is evaluating the historical EBITDA projections vs. actual. Based on our review, management was overly optimistic about access to milk for production, and EBITDA margins have materially declined."

"Part II: Twist’s “DNA chip” narrative - 10,000X higher throughput and lower cost - is fraudulent, covering up a manual, labor-intensive, and fatally-flawed manufacturing process crippled by errors, bottlenecks, and pitiful yields – thereby driving gross margins we estimate to be negative, not unlike Theranos which claimed to run blood tests on its “chip” but wasn’t."

"When AMR eliminated its Trading & Logistics segment in Q2 2019, it was merged with the CAPP Met segment. We investigated to see how AMR would restate its historical financials by combining these two segments. In the 2019 Annual Report, we see that AMR restated the segment which resulted in the segment's coal margins magically increasing by 4.7% without explanation."

"We believe that if Quectel were added to the Covered List that it would not only be a headwind to government (and perhaps all sector) sales, but it would also necessitate a widespread replacement of existing hardware, which would be accompanied by a requisite write-off of capitalized connected device costs, thus further compressing Samsara gross margins."

"Management touted Antuit as a "high-margin SaaS business" with revenue growth that doubled over a 3-year period. However, after obtaining Antuit's financial statements, we observe that revenue growth flat-lined in the year leading up to the acquisition, and its gross margin at 46.7% is wildly below the 70%-80% margins of typical SaaS companies."

"When I joined the business I think we had a 15% gross margin, but this just wasn't sustainable at that level of profit. And so the last round of label negotiations was about elevating the margins to a point where, I think, the business would self-sustain...So what was good for Spotify was good for the labels and that's why the margin increased."

"BR claims that management is compensated on segment profit, allowing it to elect to record certain segment operating and non-operating expense items in “Other”. However, this does not appear to be true as recent Proxy Statements do not reward management at all based on “segment profit”. As a result, segment margins are potentially inflated."

"With the FOIA data collected from the Florida DOT indicating a -22% decline in contact awards, and ROAD's commentary that new backlog over the period that Florida revenues ramped supported higher margins, we estimate the impact to the Company's EBITDA in FY25 to be approximately $10 - $15 million or approximately 3% - 5% of EBITDA."

"Heska's gross margins generally fall between those of high value-added diagnostic equipment companies and pure animal health distributors. Heska's EBITDA margins fall below those of nearly all possible comparable companies. We believe this is indicative of Heska's lack of proprietary technology and poor competitive position."

"Coca-Cola is an iconic world-wide American brand that also depends on its “trade secret” formula and brand equity. To put WD-40’s extreme valuation in perspective, we compare the two. Not only does Coca-Cola have broader diversification, but also significantly higher margins and growth potential despite being 88x larger."

"We believe the market wildly overvalues the entirety of BR by not considering that 40% of its business is tied to low/no margin distribution revenue and services such as credit statement printing. Its gross margins and capex spending (due to aggressive capitalization of costs) are vastly below financial technology peers."

"In 2016, Deckers combined its e-commerce and retail segments into a single segment called Direct-to-Consumer (DTC). This combination in reporting makes it very difficult to isolate retail results. Allowing for a modest decline in e-commerce margins would still imply a single digit margin for retail in FY2016 and FY2017"

"LSPD has cobbled together a motley collection of assets at increasingly expensive valuations. LSPD does not disclose target EBITDA margins, and generally hasn't disclosed historical growth rates. We believe a majority of the assets lose money and had already peaked in their growth cycle prior to LSPD's acquisition."

"Optically, PGNY would like investors to believe that it is achieving significant operating leverage. In reality, the largest contributor to its operating leverage story has been its aggressive use of stock-based compensation (SBC). Netting out the benefit of SBC uncovers that PGNY’s EBITDA margins are in decline."

"Not only has Heska had challenges growing organically, but the Company's profit margins have declined materially since peaking in 2017. Both absolute margins and margin expansion since 2019 trail IDEXX Labs by a wide margin. Investors should be concerned that margins are not expected to improve for several years."

"Spruce Point believes that Dollarama is significantly overvalued based on its undifferentiated and increasingly uncompetitive business model, inflated and unsustainable margins which are posed to decline, and its limited growth prospects which will restrain its ability to hit its long-term earnings expectations."

"We estimate gross profit per system will continue to drop as the solar investment tax credit steps down over the next 2 years. Lower margins and a reduced benefit for tax equity investors look to pressure an industry which already has tight margins and relies on tax equity to support their negative cash flows."

"Spruce Point does not believe that BR is justified in calling itself a SaaS company with margins that scale. In fact, its financials look nothing like a high quality SaaS company. When we benchmark BR's gross margins and deferred revenue relative to its recurring revenue, we find it to be wildly below peers."

"Spruce Point believes that Rollins' gross margins reporting is also opaque. Recently in 2022, the Company provided no qualitative discussion at all about factors affecting its performance. While we applaud recent efforts for more transparency, we believe gross margin discussion could be enhanced further."

"With no gross margin volatility, EBITDA margins consistently expand. USCR has offered an identical boilerplate explanation that it is related to volume, pricing, and efficiencies, up until recently. We will explore how aggressive use of capital leases likely explain some of the EBITDA margin expansion."

"Lasertec is an extreme, textbook accounting fraud that checks off every box: claiming to have the highest margins in the industry; but alarmingly little cash flow and the lowest cash conversion among its peers; accompanied by the highest inventory level of any semicap equipment supplier in the world."

"Part of the reason we struggle to underwrite Box's story of accelerating growth and expanding margins is the fact that Box has discussed initiatives to accelerate growth in the past, but not delivered on it, and has had several different target models, consistently needing to walk them back..."

"Assuming 5-year useful lives for the intangibles related to customer lists from the Credit Karma and Mailchimp acquisitions results in estimated 21% to 26% reductions in GAAP net income in each of the past three fiscal years and a near halving of GAAP net margins since FY 2020 from 24% to 14%."

"Arconic originally projected that Firth Rixson would do $2 billion of revenue in 2019. At the same margins as originally projected for 2016 (i.e., conservatively assuming no incremental volume leverage), Firth Rixson will produce approximately 50% less EBITDA than originally targeted for 2019"

"An interview with a former SafeCharge (now Nuvei) employee confirmed our belief that Nuvei entered the European gaming market as its existing retail business became more competitive. This higher risk business allowed for a recent uplift in margins which we believe will be unsustainable."

"The deterioration of Skechers' cash flow margins since 2018, coupled with a history of mismatch between its CFO and net income (before non-controlling interest) and thus highly suspect earnings quality, suggests that something is fundamentally wrong with the Company's financial model."

"We struggle to explain how gross margins expanded in the face of a structural decline of inventory turnover, and a material drop in revenues in 2015 (from emerging market challenges), and the Swiss National Bank unexpectedly changing policy in early 2015 to strengthen the Swiss Franc."

"Ancora is concerned that this may have potentially been an attempt to “juice” the stock ahead of the nomination deadline by providing an incomplete picture considering the financial metrics indicated a strong top-line performance, but no detail was offered regarding margins/earnings."

"With healthy growth continuing into the 2030s, GAAP EBIT margins in the 21% range, an 11.7% WACC, and a 17.5x EV / LTM EBITDA exit multiple (relative to a current small-cap WFE average of 24x), we get a $72 per share fair value for ACMR, representing 300%+ upside from current levels."

"The ports business is a highly profitable business, recording margins significantly higher than the European freight business - we estimate BOL's ports business generates EBITDA margins of approximately 40%, vs. an estimate of approximately 5% for its freight forwarding business."

"It appears that Smart2Pay’s approximately 50 employees were to join Nuvei. This further calls into question how could its margins increase so dramatically in the absence of significant cost reductions. LinkedIn employment trends also show no indication of employment attrition."

"A possible motivation for these inventory transfers would be to overstate gross margins by moving high cost inventory to PP&E, or eliminate the need to write-down obsolete/slow-moving inventory in the current period, and instead depreciate the expense over a 3-5 year period."

"Xylem's financial reporting has become even more opaque specifically around gross margins. Notice carefully that, not only does Xylem not quantify the impact of the Evoqua acquisition on its gross margin, but also it provides no quantitative measures of any impacts at all."

"Kornit trades at a meaningful premium to direct digital printing peers it competes with, as well as its second largest print customer which is struggling, on the belief that its 20%+ revenue growth rate is sustainable and its margins are better than peers and will expand."

"The market expects FIGS to continue top-line growth in the mid 20% range while accelerating EBITDA margins. As a result, the market ascribes FIGS a rich revenue multiple of approximately 4x. We have shown why we believe there is substantial room for multiple compression."

"Despite a massive revenue decline of $4.8 billion from 2007 to 2012, total G&A expense has actually increased, causing G&A expense as a percentage of revenue to increase from 4.2% to 6.3% and Adjusted EBITDA margins to decline from 5.3% to 3.1% over the same time period."

"ESG & Climate segment Adj. EBITDA Margins have increased 720bps from Sept 2022 – 2023 with headcount having grown from under 1,000 to approximately 1,300 according to the Head of ESG. While Retention Rate declines and revenue growth slows, we expect margins to contract."

"As GAAP gross margins have declined, the Company's poor financial performance is shown by its negative operating and net margins. However, the Company's non-GAAP adjustments create the illusion of Sunnova being a profitable business with high Adjusted EBITDA margins."

"Management repeatedly claimed that G&K’s gross margins will improve to Cintas’ legacy margins as it was marketing the transaction to investors. Yet, it’s now very evident that management never had a way to measure or track it, thus calling its claims into question."

"In the next quarter’s Q&A, the CEO stated that “in Q1 there were ACTIS units with very low gross margin from the first lots” – without ever explaining what “first lots” means; and that “we have finished recording the sales of ACTIS with poor gross profit margins.”"

"Carvana not only trades at nosebleed levels relative to its closest peers, even on consensus revenue growth expectations we regard as too high, Carvana now trades at a premium to leading tech players, all of whom enjoy better margins and generate free cash flow."

"a vote for Trian’s nominees is a vote for four highly qualified individuals who will seek to work collaboratively with the Board to: Assess the corporate structure and determine whether management is capable of achieving best-in-class revenue growth and margins"

"TCM's and Cartoon Network's 2005E EBITDA margins are estimated to be towards the high end of the profitability of other cable networks. TNT's and CNN's estimated 2005E margins of approximately 39% and 35% respectively, fall in the mid-to low end of the range."

"No, I don't remember. $500 million—between $300 to 500 million and that basically translates to the POs that they had from Intel but the POs are at a significantly reduced price. They don't have a lot of margin on those tools, very low margins on those tools."

"Xylem has repeatedly said that conversion of digital backlog to sales is higher margin. However, according to a former high-level executive, digital sales are actually dilutive to margins and do not scale as a result of the human capital investment needed."

"Spruce Point finds clear that Saputo is struggling in Europe, and recently made modifications to its competition discussion that suggests a loss of share. We observe that the percentage of retail sales are in decline, and that EBITDA margins are declining."

"According to an expert, due to nationalistic pride of wanting to partner with Amazon, we believe there will be fiercer competition resulting in: 1) Lower margins to Kornit or, 2) A complete loss of the business to a Japanese firm with more local resources."

"Scil generated 31% gross margins in 2018 and 2019, indicative of the Company's distribution business model. Of note, the Company was barely profitable on an operating basis despite scil management receiving Wilson's praise for their operational excellence."

"Spruce Point believes DY's margins are not likely sustainable and may have benefited from various actions that may be difficult to continue. As further evidence of our concern, management has walked back talk of what its long-term EBITDA margin should be."

"P&G’s income statement has stalled since 2011, underperforming the peer average on virtually every line item including: sales growth (volume and organic growth), gross profit growth, gross margins, operating profit growth, operating margins and EPS growth"

"It is worth noting that, similar to past acquisitions, there will be some amount of MSCI shared expenses that will be allocated to the segment. These allocations will reduce the margins for Burgiss, while slightly increasing the margins in other segments."

"Based on our research, we have identified three frequent events that should result in write-offs of capitalized connected device costs, which would reduce reported gross margins. We are not confident that Samsara has been taking the requisite write-offs."

"It seems to us that if one were to overstate revenue in a global business, one wouldn't want the margins to seem glaringly out of line with peers. Therefore, we would expect that a smart person (or people) would find a way to inflate expenses as well."

"We value BR's ICS and GTO business at 1x – 2x and 2.5x – 3.0x 2022E sales, respectively, to reflect its below industry margins, and other challenges we've identified. As a result, our price target is $37.35 – $52.30, implying 65% – 75% downside risk."

"Management not only believed that the global construction market would experience robust growth, but also that GCP would be able to organically grow at twice the market rate while retaining attractive margins due to its advantaged industry position."

"Despite claims of efficient utilization of assets benefiting gross margins, ROAD's gross margins have contracted since Pre-COVID-19 and that even includes the benefit of lower margin contracts rolling off and higher inflationary projects rolling on."

"Similarly, FirstGroup's UK Bus business grew substantially prior to 2007, with stagnant revenue growth since 2008 and significant margin deterioration since 2012, while Stagecoach grew its UK Regional Bus revenues and margins during the same period"