Contrarian Corpus
Muddy Waters vs. Orient Paper, Inc.

Orient Paper, Inc. · ONP

5 decks published between 2010-07-01 and 2010-07-22 — 34 pages, 34 analysed slides total.

follow up

Timeline

Each deck in chronological order — click to open. This is the story of the campaign as it unfolded.

  1. 2010-07-01 follow up

    2010 07 ONP_Correct_Entity

    4pp · research_note

    Muddy Waters reaffirms ONP is a fraud: SAIC-filed PRC financials, impossible equipment claims, and bogus acquisitions contradict ONP's SEC filings; Strong Sell.

    N 4 V 1 C 1
  2. 2010-07-02 follow up

    2010 07 ONP_MW_Response_Pearson

    10pp · letter

    Muddy Waters stands by its ONP fraud thesis: the Baoding factory is incapable of producing reported output, and the 'rejected $300K research fee' vendetta narrative is fabricated.

    N 4 V 1 C 1
  3. 2010-07-06 follow up

    2010 07 ONP_Two_Points

    6pp · research_note

    ONP claimed to own its China operating company HBOP for 16 months when it didn't, and replaced 80% of its top 10 customers while growing sales 56.5% — both flag fraud.

    N 4 V 1 C 1
  4. 2010-07-13 follow up

    2010 07 ONP_Tangled_Web

    6pp · research_note

    ONP secretly swapped its paper-machine order from corrugating medium to kraft board to salvage a technically impossible 360,000-ton output claim, while overpaying the vendor $13-14 million.

    N 3 V 1 C 1
  5. 2010-07-22 follow up

    2010 07 ONP_One_Billion_Chinese

    8pp · research_note

    AMEX-listed Orient Paper is a Chinese reverse-merger fraud: tax records, shell-company suppliers, and customer interviews show revenues and profits are fabricated by orders of magnitude.