Contrarian Corpus
activist press release proxy fight
2017-05-30 · 4 pages

Taubman Centers, Inc. TCO

Taubman's best-in-class malls are worth ~$106/share (~70% upside), but the family's dual-class 30% voting block blocks reform — elect Litt and governance expert Elson.

Thesis

Land and Buildings, a REIT-focused activist run by Jonathan Litt, is waging a proxy fight at Taubman Centers ahead of the June 1, 2017 annual meeting, seeking to elect Litt and corporate-governance expert Charles Elson to the staggered board. Litt argues Taubman's Class-A mall portfolio is worth approximately $106 per share, roughly 70% above the current price, but entrenched governance — particularly the Taubman family's dual-class B-share structure which confers a ~30% voting block — has prevented best-in-class assets from translating into best-in-class shareholder returns. Citing support from ISS, Glass Lewis, and Egan Jones, Litt dismisses Taubman's eleventh-hour declassification pledge, announced two days before the vote and ten years after 85% of common holders supported declassification, as a 'Band-Aid on a bullet wound,' and urges shareholders to vote the GOLD proxy card.

SCQA

Situation

Taubman Centers owns a best-in-class portfolio of Class-A shopping malls, a REIT segment Land and Buildings believes will thrive despite retail's omni-channel disruption thanks to premium tenants and durable investor demand.

Complication

The Taubman family's dual-class B-share structure delivers a ~30% voting block atop a staggered board, preventing the company from closing the gap between its premium assets and peer-lagging shareholder returns despite a prior 85% declassification vote.

Resolution

Vote the GOLD proxy card on June 1, 2017 to elect Jonathan Litt and corporate-governance expert Charles Elson, installing two independent directors to drive operational, strategic, and governance reforms alongside CEO Bobby Taubman.

Reward

Land and Buildings estimates Taubman's underlying asset value at approximately $106 per share — roughly 70% upside from current levels — with additional upside available from low-hanging operational improvements.

The three reasons

  1. 1

    Taubman's Class-A malls are worth ~$106/share — roughly 70% upside from current levels

  2. 2

    Dual-class B-shares hand the Taubman family a 30% voting block and block reform

  3. 3

    Eleventh-hour board declassification is 'a Band-Aid on a bullet wound' after 85% declassification vote

Primary demands

  • Elect Jonathan Litt and Charles Elson to the Taubman Board via the GOLD proxy card
  • Dismantle the Taubman family dual-class B-share structure and its ~30% voting block
  • Replace cosmetic board-refreshment with genuine independent governance expertise
  • Close the valuation gap between Taubman's Class-A mall assets and its share price

KPIs cited

Net asset value per share
Estimated at $106/share, ~70% upside from current levels
Shareholder declassification vote
>85% of common shareholders voted to declassify the Board two years in a row, nearly 10 years before the 2017 pledge
Taubman family voting block
Dual-class B-share structure grants the family approximately 30% voting control
Land and Buildings track record
>30% annualized gross return on completed investments since firm's 2008 founding
Litt sell-side ranking
Institutional Investor #1-ranked REIT analyst for 8 of 14 years

Pattern membership

Where this document fits across the library's 12 rhetorical / structural patterns. Orange cells are present in this deck; neutral cells are not.

Slide gallery ·

No slide inventory yet

Pass-2 extraction may still be in progress for this deck.

Notes

Press release wrapping Jonathan Litt's open letter to Taubman shareholders two days before the June 1, 2017 annual meeting. Rhetoric is pointed ('Band-Aid on a bullet wound', 'ill-gotten 30% voting block') but frames cooperation with CEO Bobby Taubman if elected. Cites endorsements from ISS, Glass Lewis, and Egan Jones. Word-processor layout with Land and Buildings wordmark on page 1; no charts or slide-level craft. Stake not disclosed in this document. Campaign URL: SaveTaubman.com.