Contrarian Corpus
Phrase library

Callouts & quotes from 37,061+ activist slides

Every emphasised callout and every pulled quote, extracted slide-by-slide. Search by keyword, filter by slide type or by source.

Showing 13441–13500 of 37,061
callout villain critique

"We went back to compare its actual Capex spend vs. forecasted, particularly as it relates to its China capacity expansion, and found a consistent and repeated pattern of over-estimating Capex."

A.O. Smith Corporation · AOS Spruce Point Capital · p. 7
callout timeline

"CP's share price increased 429% (including dividends) since inception of our investment in September 2011, and 335% from our average cost basis prior to the position being made public, to date"

callout kpi overview

"Restaurant Brands International’s share price increased 176% (including dividends) since it merged with Justice Holdings and from our average cost basis prior to the position being made public"

callout villain critique

"Limiting compensation to verifiable, “Profitable Retail Sales” is a problem for Herbalife because: “Defendants’ program does not offer participants a viable retail-based business opportunity.”"

Herbalife · HLF Pershing Square · p. 27
callout villain critique

"Any volume thresholds/requirements for compensation, discounts, and advancement in the Marketing Plan must be met exclusively through “Profitable Retail Sales” and Sales to Preferred Customers"

Herbalife · HLF Pershing Square · p. 29
callout cover

"MOXC's main operating subsidiary in China, Moxian Shenzhen, and its purported VIE, Moyi Shenzhen, do not have the national licenses required to operate an online advertising business in China."

Moxian, Inc. · MOXC Wolfpack Research · p. 1
callout transition

"Effective October 29th, 2015, CVS Caremark, Express Scripts and UnitedHealth/Optum announced the termination of their relationship with Philidor, comprising the vast majority of the PBM market"

callout villain critique

"We are not convinced that PC14586 can raise wild-type p53 activity high enough, for long enough, to effectively restore normal cell function or to result in durable tumor regression in humans."

PMV Pharmaceuticals · PMVP Wolfpack Research · p. 11
callout villain critique

"Above is a screen shot of another repetitive comment, review. This time, Liang identified as many as 25 comments that were identical and repeated by different users in different WeChat groups."

GSX Techedu Inc. · GSX Grizzly Research · p. 27
callout demand list

"Selling the Company is the best and (at this point) the most viable pathway forward to solve its prolonged market issues and deliver an optimal outcome to all with a stake in Alexion’s future."

Alexion Pharmaceuticals, Inc. · ALXN Elliott Management · p. 9
callout other

"The actual percentage is likely lower, as we suspect Intel’s price is even less; and as the average is driven by earlier years ~2020/2021, we think ACTIS today is <10% of sales – if not below."

Lasertec Corporation · 6920 Scorpion Capital · p. 55
callout villain critique

"Not only the extortion-like tactics employed preceding the privatization, but also the highly unusual deal structure should have been significant red flags for TeliaSonera's board at the time."

TeliaSonera AB · TLSN Muddy Waters · p. 21
quote ceo quote

"There was indeed a fraud case; there is no protection against that. There was a whistleblower and within a very short period of time we were able to channel things properly again. — Udo Müller"

Ströer SE & Co. KGaA · SAX Muddy Waters · p. 82
quote ceo quote

"“This last contract with Rapiscan was a big kind of fallacy... They were selling something that this equipment can’t do... This is the red point on this contract.” — Former senior SAT official"

OSI Systems, Inc. · OSIS Muddy Waters · p. 17
quote appendix data

"I do not accept that the Design and Access Statement was incorporated by reference by the Planning Permission; nor that there is an ambiguity which this extrinsic document operates to resolve."

BP plc · BP Bluebell Capital · p. 25
quote villain critique

"It is not exactly clear why these changes are being made so quickly, but the negative publicity around HLF's business model probably provided a strong incentive to take action now. — Ms. Adler"

Herbalife Ltd. · HLF Pershing Square · p. 4
quote cover

"“fundamental lack of understanding of [AGO’s] business model.” — Assured Guaranty (AGO); “Mr. Einhorn’s focus on total debt service ignores this lack of acceleration.” — Assured Guaranty (AGO)"

Assured Guaranty · AGO Greenlight Capital · p. 1
quote ceo quote

"“Looking at 2010, you can expect more of the same from CP, emphasis on cost management, productivity and the realization of longer-term structural savings.” — Fred Green, Q4 2009 Earnings Call"

Canadian Pacific Railway · CP Pershing Square · p. 66
quote process diagram

"On a March 2005 conference call, Mr. Parsons said that cable companies “have a complexity of balance sheet and financial structure that is very different from a content company…” — Mr. Parsons"

Time Warner Inc. · TWX Carl Icahn · p. 283
quote villain critique

"Gross proceeds from the three disposals were nearly €80 million. On average, sales took place at prices which are similar to the June 2023 book value. — CPI PG Press Release dated Feb 28, 2024"

quote villain critique

"The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) has recommended strict penal action, including imprisonment, for auditors who are found associated with serious accounting frauds. — ICAI"

Mettler-Toledo International, Inc. · MTD Spruce Point Capital · p. 28
quote appendix data

"The ventilation of Agreed Issue [A1.4c] attracted resistance from the Council and the Developer. They characterised it as inappropriate ‘rolling judicial review’. But this resistance subsided."

BP plc · BP Bluebell Capital · p. 15
quote villain critique

"“The role is CSC, which is a joint venture with IQE and Cardiff University. Essentially though it is the same contract as all other IQE employees and is based at our site in Cardiff.” — IQE HR"

IQE plc · IQE Muddy Waters · p. 11
quote ceo quote

"flawless transition to a new more efficient, primary logistics and warehouse provider with no interruption to the business — Compensation and Talent Management Committee (2020 Proxy Statement)"

Prestige Consumer Healthcare Inc. · PBH Spruce Point Capital · p. 112
quote villain critique

"I'm not reaching out to people proactively...I'm letting them reach out to me and a couple have...because they are following the story. — Trial investigator, pediatrician/geneticist, professor"

Soleno Therapeutics · SLNO Scorpion Capital · p. 315
quote ceo quote

"I think history shows us that breaking up large energy companies is not only possible, but it also unlocks significant value. We've seen this time and time again in energy... — Stacy Nieuwoudt"

Phillips 66 · PSX Elliott Management · p. 16
quote villain critique

"Хотел бы уточнить о возможности размещения четырех детей из ДНР в вашем отеле 22-27 марта 2026 г. для размещения их в семьи. Милые девочки возрастом 14-16 лет. Красотки! — Sender of the email."

Accor SA · AC Grizzly Research · p. 84
quote villain critique

"Is it possible to book a private massage session with some young and beautiful female Filipino ladies? Is it possible to receive massage in my room? — Guest email to Mövenpick Hotel Islamabad."

Accor SA · AC Grizzly Research · p. 215
quote villain critique

"Is it possible to book a private massage session with some young and beautiful female Filipino ladies? Is it possible to receive massage in my room? — Guest email to Mövenpick Hotel Islamabad."

Accor SA · AC Grizzly Research · p. 218
quote villain critique

"We have a similar approach. We have taken away ID, because many labs in Europe have already invested in MALDI and that solution is good. So we can reduce the price of our product. — Qlinea rep"

Accelerate Diagnostics · AXDX White Diamond Research · p. 9
callout villain critique

"Spruce Point observes that Remitly modified its definition of active customer in a manner that broadens its potential to inflate active customers by considering them over an undefined period."

Remitly Global, Inc. · RELY Spruce Point Capital · p. 24
callout other

"We spoke with a Senior NFL Employee who discussed the economics of the deal, that Genius will be committing to invest additional capital in an innovation fund, and potential risks for Genius."

Genius Sports Limited · GENI Spruce Point Capital · p. 35
callout peer gap

"Avery is expensive relative to its specialty chemical and materials peers, even before our adjustments to its enterprise value for added debts, and normalization of EBITDA and Free Cash Flow."

Avery Dennison Corporation · AVY Spruce Point Capital · p. 87
callout ceo quote

"SPI alleges FIGS made exaggerated representations regarding its products' antimicrobial properties, at times failing to definitively respond to requests for scientific support for its claims."

FIGS, Inc. · FIGS Spruce Point Capital · p. 105
callout other

"With almost 1.1 million water customers, what benefit does WTRG get from acquiring an asset that both: 1) Has just 2,300 customers that barely moves the needle, and 2) Has no customer growth?"

Essential Utilities, Inc. · WTRG Spruce Point Capital · p. 39
callout appendix methodology

"If that number he cited was inclusive of the franchises, which constitute 55% of Firstleap's centers but generate little revenue, then the deferred revenue overstatement is even more hideous."

TAL Education Group · TAL Muddy Waters · p. 7
callout ceo quote

"Zayo is the largest pure-play provider of fiber infrastructure in the U.S. and, consistent with American Tower and SBA, has concluded that many small cell deals are not attractive investments"

Crown Castle International · CCI Elliott Management · p. 47
callout valuation reveal

"We believe CCI could conservatively trade at a 4.0% dividend yield in this scenario, providing a significantly lower cost of capital and driving 27% upside to the Company's recent share price"

callout precedent table

"The carved out entity reported EBITDA that was $229 million higher than what was reported in the same year inside DuPont, meaning 500bps of costs were allocated to Axalta and stayed at DuPont"

Solventum Corporation · SOLV Trian Partners · p. 21
callout ceo quote

"Recent sell-in was a market-driven opportunity as HCM Beyond Payroll gained widespread adoption. Future growth will be challenged without a best-in-class HCM product suite driving “new logos”"

callout peer gap

"Keisei executives have the highest fixed pay in the peer group. Fixed pay rose by 10.9% from FY23 to FY24. Keisei have not introduced variable compensation since they began reporting in 2019."

Keisei Electric Railway · 9009 Palliser Capital · p. 25
callout other

"IPX has been talking about a Japanese customer evaluation with a conglomerate since mid 2023 and that additional lab testing in Australia has been on going since September 2024 (over 1 year)."

IperionX Ltd. · IPX Spruce Point Capital · p. 53
callout appendix data

"The Company has destroyed its credibility with investors and shown an inability to create shareholder value, so action must be taken immediately to enable Phillips to reach its full potential"

Phillips 66 · PSX Elliott Management · p. 51
callout ceo quote

"He stated that anybody “tinkering” with IonQ’s device “isn’t really doing anything”; that the type of computation one can do with it is “trivial”; and that the machine is “not really useful.”"

IonQ Inc. · IONQ Scorpion Capital · p. 135
callout other

"We find it interesting that management raised the price of G5 transmitters such that the annual cost of continuing to use a hacked G5 is now almost identical to the annual cost of using a G6."

Dexcom, Inc. · DXCM Spruce Point Capital · p. 69
callout villain critique

"The stock price reflects concern about ballooning capital costs, chronic lack of free cash flow, a high oil price breakeven, and recent difficulty executing against guidance and expectations."

Hess Corporation · HES Elliott Management · p. 36
callout demand list

"Despite McDonald's' hollow attempts to miscast some of our "demands," the reality is our asks are completely reasonable and can help the Board restore its broken credibility with shareholders"

callout ceo quote

"However, a check online indicates that approximately 78%-95% of the boots are >$100 which suggests that BOOT is stuck with a significant quantity of high-priced inventory that is not selling."

Boot Barn Holdings, Inc. · BOOT Spruce Point Capital · p. 41
callout valuation reveal

"With its miniscule share count (appx 7.8 million shares outstanding, including Lynrock’s free warrants) any Edge Computing multiple will sweep this stock 6-10x up from current levels or more."

Edgio, Inc. · EGIO Citron Research · p. 11
callout ceo quote

"Only 11 months ago, management said it was “absolutely committed” to driving unit costs down in 2024. Today, management is guiding to a 7-8% increase, representing $1.7B of incremental costs."

Unknown · p. 46
callout precedent table

"There are numerous examples of accounting errors and scandals tied to misestimating revenues and costs with long-term projects, especially in the Communications, Aerospace and Defense sector."

Maxar Technologies · MAXR Spruce Point Capital · p. 21
callout other

"Abnormal increase in the Capex / Depreciation and Amortization ratio of SSL pre and post acquisition by MDA in 2012 should be carefully scrutinized and suggest overcapitalization of expenses."

Maxar Technologies · MAXR Spruce Point Capital · p. 26
callout kpi overview

"The online experiences category is expected to grow in the teens, driven by the shift from offline to online channels and growth of the overall category of tours, activities, and attractions."

Tripadvisor, Inc. · TRIP Starboard Value · p. 16
callout demand list

"If the Company pursues this standalone path, follows our recommendations and makes the necessary changes, we believe the stock could be worth between $22 and $26 per share at the end of 2027."

Avantor, Inc. · AVTR Engine Capital · p. 11
callout villain critique

"But, Cost Curve claims should not be confused with “operational improvement.” The majority of gains on the cost curve have been because of smelter closures and Ma’aden, not better operations."

Arconic Inc. · ARNC Elliott Management · p. 321
callout appendix data

"The Company has destroyed its credibility with investors and shown an inability to create shareholder value, so action must be taken immediately to enable Phillips to reach its full potential"

Phillips 66 · PSX Elliott Management · p. 51
callout peer gap

"AMR’s portrayal of its “Non-GAAP Cost of Coal Sales” is highly liberal when compared with peers. We see observe it is making five beneficial adjustments, whereas most peers make two or three."

Alpha Metallurgical Resources, Inc. · AMR Spruce Point Capital · p. 47
callout villain critique

"Further inquiries yielded additional red flags: an employee at the Abu Dhabi Health Department related to investigators that the purchase price was “unbelievable” for what was classified as a"

NMC Health plc · NMC.LN Muddy Waters · p. 13
callout ceo quote

"We estimate she has sold ~$70MM of stock; co-founder and SVP Bill Banyai, ~$42MM; CFO Jim Thorburn, ~$15MM; and President/COO Patrick Finn, ~$11MM – a total of $135MM across these four alone."

Twist Bioscience · TWST Scorpion Capital · p. 33
callout villain critique

"Stopped giving Twist complex orders, only simple, commodity ones; orders take multiples longer than the short lead times Twist advertises; weeks to months vs. days as Twist states on its site"

Twist Bioscience · TWST Scorpion Capital · p. 148