Contrarian Corpus
activist full deck follow up
2025-01-16 · 104 pages

Fannie Mae / Freddie Mac FNMA / FMCC

Release Fannie and Freddie from conservatorship at a 2.5% capital standard and IPO them at ~$30+/share; Treasury's warrants generate ~$300bn while shares re-rate 5-6x from ~$6 today.

Thesis

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have been in government conservatorship since 2008 and now hold $131bn of retained capital, enough to stand alone. Pershing Square argues FHFA's 2020 capital rule of 4% is impractical — it would tie up ~$100bn of wasted capital and force g-fee hikes that effectively tax American homebuyers. A 2.5% standard, benchmarked against banks and private mortgage insurers, gives the GSEs $286bn of Claims Paying Resources, more than 10x their actual 2007-2011 losses excluding subprime and Alt-A. The four-step framework: set 2.5% capital, strip government-granted benefits, install market-based governance, clarify the backstop. Fannie IPOs in 2026 at ~$32/share and Freddie in 2027 at ~$34, re-rating to ~$35 and ~$39 at full recapitalization versus ~$6 today. Treasury's 79.9% warrants could deliver ~$300bn to taxpayers. The incoming Trump administration has a four-year runway to act.

SCQA

Situation

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are GSEs guaranteeing ~$7.6 trillion of US single-family mortgages, operating in government conservatorship since 2008 and now holding $131bn of retained capital.

Complication

FHFA's 2020 capital rule of 4% is impractical — it would tie up ~$100bn of wasted capital, force g-fee hikes that tax homebuyers, and make a private recapitalization uneconomic.

Resolution

Set capital at 2.5%, strip non-vital government benefits, IPO Fannie in 2026 and Freddie in 2027, and treat Treasury's Senior Preferred as repaid rather than convert it to common.

Reward

Fannie could be worth ~$35/share by YE 2026 and Freddie ~$39 by YE 2027 — versus ~$6 today — while Treasury's warrants generate ~$300bn for taxpayers, more than all other bailout profits combined.

The three reasons

  1. 1

    A 2.5% capital rule gives GSEs a fortress balance sheet with 10x actual 2007-2011 core losses

  2. 2

    Treasury's 79.9% warrants could generate ~$300bn for taxpayers — more than all prior bailouts combined

  3. 3

    Fannie worth ~$35 by YE 2026, Freddie ~$39 by YE 2027 — vs. ~$6 today

Primary demands

  • Release Fannie and Freddie from FHFA conservatorship via Treasury/FHFA action (no Congress needed)
  • Set minimum capital requirement at 2.5% (vs. FHFA's current 4% rule)
  • Limit non-vital government-granted benefits (SEC exemption, UST $2.25bn line, Volcker exemption, FSOC exemption)
  • IPO Fannie Mae ~$5bn in 2026 and Freddie Mac ~$15bn in 2027
  • Treat Treasury's Senior Preferred Stock as repaid — do NOT convert into common equity
  • Exercise Treasury's 79.9% warrants and monetize over time to generate ~$300bn for taxpayers

KPIs cited

Average g-fee (bps)
Long-term average ~30bps since 1990; current 64bps FNMA / 67bps FMCC
Single-family guarantee portfolio
~$6.7-7.6tn outstanding; 88% of total GSE guarantees
Capital ratio
Pre-GFC 0.45%; FHFA 2020 rule 4%; Pershing proposed 2.5%
Cumulative credit losses 2007-2011
$46bn actual; $27bn excl. subprime & Alt-A; $138bn including provisions
Claims Paying Resources at 2.5%
$286bn total = $168bn equity + $101bn future g-fees + $17bn crisis optionality (10.6x core GFC losses)
Treasury dividends received
$301bn paid on $191bn disbursed; 11.6% IRR; $25bn above 10% contractual rate
Subprime/Alt-A share of Fannie losses
Up to 48% of credit losses from ~10% of portfolio in 2008
Bank Tier 1 minimum for residential mortgages
3.5%-4.7% (anchor comparison)
PMI minimum capital
5.6% PMIERs ratio
2035E ROE / EPS
FNMA 12.5% ROE, $2.97 EPS; FMCC 10.6% ROE, $3.34 EPS
Implied IPO share price
FNMA $31.81 at 12/31/26 (10% IPO discount); FMCC $33.77 at 12/31/27 (15% IPO discount)
IPO size
Fannie $5bn in 2026; Freddie $15bn in 2027
Trading multiple benchmark
50/50 P&C / utility blend = ~14x P/E, ~2.1x BV
Treasury common warrant stake
79.9% of both companies

Pattern membership

Where this document fits across the library's 12 rhetorical / structural patterns. Orange cells are present in this deck; neutral cells are not.

Precedents cited

  • GGP 're-IPO' 2009-2010 (Pershing/Fairholme/BAM)
  • AIG, GM, Citi, BofA, JPM, Wells Fargo, Chrysler bailout recoveries
  • Saudi Aramco, Alibaba, SoftBank, AIA, Visa, GM, Facebook IPO precedents

Composition what's on the 104 slides

Visual + textual elements counted across every slide in this deck. Hover a box for what that element is; click to see every slide in the corpus that uses it.

Slide gallery ·

All 104
No slide inventory yet

Pass-2 extraction may still be in progress for this deck.

Notes

Cover titled 'The Art of the Deal' — framed explicitly as a pitch to the incoming Trump administration, closing with a Trump 'Art of the Deal' quote. Long-running Pershing Square position (Ackman public on FNMA/FMCC since ~2013); this 2025 deck is policy advocacy toward Trump Treasury/FHFA rather than corporate activism. Disclaimer confirms 'Funds managed by Pershing Square and its affiliates own shares, predominantly common stock' but no percent stake disclosed. Four-step framework (capital / benefits / governance / backstop) is the structural spine. Heavy use of authority quotes (Greenspan, Buffett, Mortgage Bankers Association, KBW, Cato Institute, amicus briefs) for credentialing. Implicit villain is FHFA's 4% capital rule and the 2012 Net Worth Sweep, not a named individual. Watermarked '10XEBITDA.com' throughout (third-party redistribution); authorship unambiguously Pershing Square. No named author on cover — hence author_name null.